Summary dismissal under § 626 BGB — almost always defensible.
A summary dismissal ends your employment immediately and triggers a 12-week unemployment-benefit blocking period. Most summary dismissals fail the strict § 626 BGB test — and settle with substantial severance.
⚠ Same 3-week filing deadline applies (§ 4 KSchG)
A summary dismissal must be challenged within 3 weeks of receipt — even when the ground is plainly weak.
A summary dismissal under § 626 BGB requires a wichtiger Grund — a cause so serious that continuing the employment even for the notice period is unreasonable. The bar is extremely high. The employer must additionally act within 2 weeks of obtaining knowledge of the cause (§ 626 II BGB), usually issue an Abmahnung first, and prove the cause in court if challenged. In practice the great majority of summary dismissals fail and settle with severance materially above the standard 0.5×-per-year formula.
Written and reviewed by Fatih Bektas, German employment-law specialist (APOS Legal Heidelberg).
The two-step test under § 626 BGB
German labour courts review every summary dismissal in two strictly separate steps. The employer must survive both. If either step fails, the summary dismissal is invalid — and the employment relationship continues as if the dismissal had never been issued.
- Abstract capability (Step 1): Is the alleged conduct, considered in the abstract, in principle capable of justifying summary dismissal? Examples that pass this threshold: theft, assault, serious fraud, continued refusal to work after warning. Examples that fail already here: a single minor incident, isolated tardiness, a tone-of-voice complaint.
- Interessenabwägung (Step 2): Even if Step 1 is passed, a comprehensive balancing of interests must find in the employer’s favour. Factors: duration of employment, prior conduct, personal circumstances, whether an Abmahnung would have sufficed, and the realistic prospect of continued cooperation. Long tenure and a clean record tilt the scale strongly in the employee’s favour.
BAG 10 October 2002 — the Emmely framework
In the Emmely line of cases the Federal Labour Court made clear that Abmahnung is the rule even for property offences at the employer’s expense, provided the breach is reparable in the sense that future conduct can realistically be restored to the standard required by the contract. A long and unblemished employment relationship is a strong factor in the employee’s favour.
Auch bei Vermögensdelikten zu Lasten des Arbeitgebers ist eine Abmahnung nicht entbehrlich, wenn das pflichtwidrige Verhalten steuerbar und eine Wiederherstellung des Vertrauens erwartbar ist.
English rendering: Even in property offences committed to the employer’s disadvantage, a prior warning is not dispensable where the breach is controllable and restoration of trust can realistically be expected. Read the judgment on dejure.org →
When does § 626 BGB actually apply?
Possible serious grounds
- Theft, embezzlement, fraud at the employer’s expense
- Violence or serious harassment at work
- Repeated unauthorised absence after warnings
- Severe breach of trust (e.g. trade-secret leaks)
- Insulting the employer on a public scale
Routine reasons summary dismissals fail
- 2-week deadline (§ 626 II BGB) missed
- No prior Abmahnung where one was required
- Cause is contested and the employer cannot prove it
- Disproportionate to the breach
- No works-council consultation (§ 102 BetrVG)
The hidden cost: 12-week unemployment-benefit blocking period
A summary dismissal has a second financial consequence that is often more painful than the dismissal itself: the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) as a rule imposes a 12-week Sperrzeit (§ 159 I SGB III), during which no unemployment benefit is paid. The maximum entitlement is additionally shortened by a quarter.
Example — Sperrzeit arithmetic:
Monthly ALG I entitlement €2,100 · 12-week Sperrzeit · 3 months without benefit = −€6,300. On top of that, the entitlement period is shortened by a quarter — a further loss that scales with how long you have contributed to unemployment insurance.
A successful court settlement that converts the summary dismissal into an ordinary dismissal removes the Sperrzeit in most cases — a core strategic reason to challenge every summary dismissal that is not plainly justified.
What to do in the first 24 hours
- Note the exact date and time of receipt — the 3-week clock starts here.
- Do not sign anything the employer puts in front of you.
- Send us a copy of the dismissal letter — a German employment-law specialist reviews it for free within 48 hours.
- Register as job-seeker (arbeitsuchend) within 3 days to preserve benefit entitlement.
- If you have legal-expenses insurance, notify your provider now so cover is in place when we file.
Summary dismissal — most common questions
What counts as a summary (without-notice) dismissal in Germany?
A summary dismissal (fristlose Kündigung) under § 626 BGB ends the employment immediately without observing any notice period. It requires a serious cause that makes it unreasonable for the employer to continue the relationship even until the end of the notice period — a very high hurdle.
What is the 2-week rule?
Under § 626 II BGB the employer must declare the summary dismissal within 2 weeks of obtaining full knowledge of the cause. If the deadline is missed the summary dismissal is invalid — a frequent winning argument in court.
Do I get severance after a summary dismissal?
There is no automatic severance, but in practice summary dismissals very often settle with substantial severance, precisely because they so frequently fail in court. Settlements are commonly higher than after an ordinary dismissal because the employer faces a strong risk of complete invalidity.
Does the employer have to warn me first?
Usually yes. For most conduct, a prior Abmahnung is required so you had a chance to correct the behaviour. Only in cases of fundamental breach of trust (theft, fraud, violence) can a summary dismissal be valid without a prior warning.
What about unemployment benefit?
A summary dismissal regularly triggers a 12-week Sperrzeit under § 159 I SGB III. Challenging the dismissal is therefore not only about reinstatement / severance — it also protects your access to unemployment benefit, because a settlement converting the summary dismissal to an ordinary one usually removes the Sperrzeit. The maximum entitlement period is additionally shortened by a quarter if the Sperrzeit stands.
How is severance calculated after a summary dismissal?
There is no statutory formula. Settlements regularly land between 0.5 and 1.5 gross monthly salaries per year of service, often higher where the summary dismissal has weak evidential foundation, where the 2-week deadline is in doubt or where no Abmahnung preceded the dismissal. The weaker the employer’s case, the stronger the employee’s negotiating position — in some cases far above the 0.5× anchor used for ordinary redundancy dismissals.
What if the dismissal letter is signed only by the Personalleiter?
The signatory must have power of attorney to dismiss. If the HR manager (Personalleiter) signs without written authority and did not visibly notify you of their power before, you may reject the dismissal without delay under § 174 BGB — meaning within about a week. If accepted, this makes the dismissal invalid for formal reasons alone.
Tell us about your case
Fill in the form — we will review your situation. Free of charge, typically within 48 hours. We handle German labour-law matters in English.
What happens next?
After your enquiry we review the details and reply with an initial assessment — whether the dismissal can be challenged, how high a likely severance could be and which next steps make sense.
bektas@apos.legal
+49 6222 9599 2400
Response time: we reply within 48 hours on working days. If you have already received a dismissal, please mention it — deadline-sensitive cases are prioritised.
Dismissed? The clock is ticking.
Tell us about your case — we check for free whether your dismissal can be challenged and how high your severance can be. Usually within 48 hours.
Get my free review →Received a dismissal? You have just 3 weeks to file (§ 4 KSchG). Contact us immediately — we can protect your deadline while reviewing the case.